Soteria Insurance Group


Foundations of our Relationship


Trust is a big thing to ask for, but we have to ask for it.


Insurance is just a promise to pay, in this business our word is our bond.

Hard Work

Working hard is what we do, and we do it for you.


New ideas can help save money and expand coverage.

Property and Casualty Insurance

Commercial Lines

Property  /  General Liability

Workers Compensation  /  Automobile

Inland Marine  /  Ocean Marine

Cyber Liability  /  Aviation

Drone  /  Crime

Employment Practices Liability

Directors & Officers Liability

Errors and Omissions Liability

Fiduciary Liability


Personal Lines

Primary Residence

Secondary Residence

Seasonal Residence

Automobile  /  Boat

Personal Liability  /  Umbrella

ATV  /  Dirt-bike  /  Golf Cart

Your Team

Luke Cathcart - President & Chief Everything Officer

Luke Cathcart started his insurance journey at Ball State University, where he graduated with his University Associate Risk Manager designation and majored in Risk Management and Insurance. He originally enrolled in the Miller College of Business as a Finance major, and with a couple more semesters he would have triple majored in Finance, Economics, and Risk Management and Insurance. 

As an intern for Protective Insurance Luke was offered an underwriting position prior but it meant he had to drop the two additional majors. Eager to get into the insurance industry, Luke dropped the two majors and was underwriting small fleet trucking exposures before he graduated. 

He left Protective Insurance to join Gallagher, the 4th largest insurance broker, in the world, at that time. While at Gallagher he dealt with all lines of commercial property and casualty and worked on a diverse book of business. His clients included: engineers, general construction companies, contractors, cities, towns, public entities, real estate developers, auto dealers, and manufacturing.

He quickly fell in love with the opportunity of helping people buy insurance and decided it was time to build his legacy. He started Soteria Insurance Group on December 5th, 2019. 

Luke is passionate about helping his clients understand their exposures and the coverage available. As an independent broker Luke doesn't just represent an insurance company, he represents his clients to the companies and markets the client's exposures/risk to an extensive list of carriers. He will endeavor to obtain as many quotes as possible through the standard and excess markets. Once the policies are in place, Luke will be your go to guy for everything property and casualty insurance. 

Contact Us

Schedule a Free Policy Assessment

Soteria Insurance Group

4717 Crittenden Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205 US

(317) 225-6105


Feel free to call or text, Luke may not answer right away but he will be in contact as soon as he can. Night or day, weekend or holiday.